top of page

What Happened with SmileDirectClub, and What We Think Is Worth Knowing

Writer: Brandy Solomon
Brandy Solomon
Nov 4
4 min read

If you have ever been drawn in by ads for affordable, mail-order clear aligners, you are certainly not alone. Millions of people were, and it is easy to see why. The idea was appealing: straighten your teeth from home, skip extra appointments, and spend less along the way.


SmileDirectClub, the largest company behind that idea, filed for bankruptcy in 2023 and closed its doors, leaving many patients mid-treatment without support. A separate company, SmileSet, later acquired its technology and assets.


We do not share this to cast judgment. We believe SmileDirectClub set out to make orthodontic care more accessible, and that is a goal we respect. What we would love to offer here is an honest, educated perspective on what happened, and what it can teach any of us about choosing an aligner provider, direct-to-consumer or otherwise.


The SmileDirectClub Story

SmileDirectClub launched in 2014 with an innovative idea: deliver custom clear aligners directly to customers, use remote monitoring instead of office visits, and make treatment more accessible and affordable. For a while, it worked well. The company grew quickly, went public in 2019, and by its own count helped more than two million people, a real sign of how much people wanted this kind of access to care.


Over time, though, challenges began to surface. Reports in 2019 counted more than 1,600 Better Business Bureau complaints over a three-year span. The company said many involved shipping delays. Some patients reported teeth not tracking as expected, bite changes during treatment, and difficulty reaching support when questions came up. A number of lawsuits followed, from consumers, state attorneys general, and others.


By late 2023, SmileDirectClub filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, and in December it stopped operating altogether, leaving patients mid-treatment without a provider and with refund questions unresolved. We hope everyone affected found the support they needed.


Why In-Person, Supervised Care Matters

Moving teeth is a beautifully precise process. It involves gentle, controlled force on living tissue: bone remodels, ligaments stretch, and roots shift gradually within the jaw. When it is done thoughtfully and monitored closely, it is safe and predictable. Without that oversight, it is simply harder to catch and adjust for the small issues that come up along the way.


We think the real challenge with the direct-to-consumer model was never the aligners themselves. It was more about the level of support built around them: treatment plans with limited clinician involvement, no in-person evaluations, and fewer ways to make adjustments if a tooth was not responding quite as expected.


In our office, we check your progress at regular in-person visits. If something is not moving quite right, we adjust the plan together. If your bite starts shifting in an unexpected way, we catch it early. And if aligners end up not being the ideal tool for a particular movement, we have other options ready.

Dr. Solomon designs your treatment plan herself, planning each tooth movement and approving every step. Invisalign is a wonderful company that we have worked with for years, and it fabricates your aligners to the plan she prescribes. Invisalign makes the aligners, and Dr. Solomon decides what they are designed to do.


What We Would Gently Encourage You to Look For in Any Provider

An in-person evaluation before treatment begins, so your teeth, bite, gums, and jaw can be seen and felt by a licensed professional, not just photographed.


A specialist designing and approving your treatment plan. Aligner companies fabricate the aligners, but the tooth movements they are built to achieve should be planned by the clinician who is guiding your care.


Regular in-person check-ins throughout treatment, not just photo uploads to an app, so someone is always looking closely at your progress.

The flexibility to adjust course if aligners are not working as hoped, because having options matters.

A retention plan built in from the very beginning, since teeth naturally want to settle back over time, and a thoughtful plan accounts for that from day one.


If You Started with a Mail-Order Aligner and It Did Not Go as Hoped

If your results were not quite what you expected, maybe your teeth did not fully straighten, your bite feels a little off, or you were left without support when a company closed, please know that is completely normal. We see this often, and it is almost always fixable.


We would be happy to take a look at where your treatment stands, talk through what would help, and build a plan to get you closer to the smile you were hoping for, this time with steady, in-person support along the way.


A Gentle Closing Thought

Clear aligners have helped many people feel more confident in their smiles, and the technology behind them is impressive. What matters most, we believe, is pairing that technology with thoughtful, hands-on clinical care.


If you would like a specialist's honest, unhurried perspective, whether you are just starting out or picking back up after a previous experience, we would love to see you for a complimentary consultation.


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page